June 19, 2007

  • Introductions

    Having
    finished one book, I’m starting three. 

    Three books, three introductions. 

    Ursula
    K. Le Guin’s opening paragraph to Buffalo
    Gals and Other Animal Presences
    resonated with me.  I, too, prefer to read the introduction after I’ve read the book, a behavior
    I’ve never heard spoken of before.  Any
    one else do this? 

    Having done introductions before, I
    have found that many readers loathe them,
    reviewers sneer at them, and critics
    dismiss them; and then they all tell
    me so.  As for myself, I rather like
    introductions, but generally read them
    after reading what they were supposed to introduce me to.  Read as extra-ductions,
    they are often interesting and useful. 
    But that won’t do.  Ductions must be intro, and come first, like
    salad in restaurants, a lot of  cardboard
    lettuce with bits of red wooden cabbage soaked in dressing, so that you’re disabled for the entrée.

     


    Thomas
    Cahill’s latest book in his Hinges of History series, Mysteries of the Middle Ages, The Rise of Feminism, Science, and Art
    from the Cults of Catholic Europe
    , is a lush, beautiful book.  The type, sidebars, illustrations, yea, even
    the paper announce: this book is special. 
    I’m unsure of his premises and am feeling a bit reserved about the book.  But these words warmed me:

     

    All across Europe,
    a pilgrimage in company with others was a life-defining event and one of the
    principal satisfactions of a well-tuned life. […]  I invite
    you on a pilgrimage, dear Reader.  Come
    along with me (and many others) to places
    we have never seen before and to people we could  otherwise never have expected to know. We are surely
    sundry folk, as Chaucer would have
    called us, and we shall meet sundry folk even more exotic than ourselves.  “By
    adventure”—by happenstance—we have fallen into
    fellowship.

     

    Barbara
    Tuchman’s introduction to A Distant
    Mirror, The Calamitous 14th Century
      provided the best reason I’ve
    ever read for learning historical dates– in one short sentence.  Oh man, this revved my engine.

    Dates may seem dull and pedantic to
    some, but they are fundamental because
    they establish sequence—what precedes and what follows—thereby leading toward an understanding of cause and effect.

    Here’s a sequence I’ve pondered, one I’ve never seen mentioned in
    print.  What does The Fall of Constantinople
    to the
    Ottoman Empire in 1453 have to do with
    Luther’s Reformation of 1517?  Have you
    ever wondered why Martin Luther died from natural causes at the age of 62, when
    many reformers/heretics were burned at the stake before and after him?  Charles V wanted to deal with Luther, but the
    Ottoman Turks were knocking at the door of
    Vienna
    Hmm.  So the threat of Islam gave
    the Reformation a small period of incubation. 
    I talked to a missionary to Turks living in
    Germany and posited this
    theory.  He nodded vigorously and said
    that the connection is something many Moslems are aware of.

     

Comments (5)

  • Hmmm…..seems like a common disagreement, as the French eat their salads last.

    I like introductions and prefaces, appendices, and indices as well.

    You do such a nice job with your reviews-zeroing right into a good point.

    At the moment, I’m still covered up with Truman, Appalachian Trail, Fathers, and Ruth Graham.  However, I am planning to to pick up (again) my epic, The Dwelling  Place by Erskine Clarke.

    Dana in GA

  • Hey Carol, I love your insight into God’s Providence with Martin Luther and the reformation. Good stuff.

    A bit off topic. I have posted the excellent sermon of 6-17-07 on depression and Curt’s Re-tuning for the Lord’s Day message of 6-10-07.

    I also posted today a cute blurp of the Hos. reception with Meredith singing Baa Baa Black Sheep and Engine Engine Number Nine.

    Blessings.

    Archie

  • Hey again Carol,

    Those links are not designed to stream. Just right click and choose “save target as” and download the .mp3 file. I find Real Audio to be the simplest and most versatile audio file player (of any format) .

    Blessings.

  • Thanks Archie. If I only understood 1% of what you know about computers, audio, visual, etc. I would be happy.

    “Those links are not designed to stream.” What, exactly, does that mean? You aren’t supposed to listen to them in real time? (As if I know what “real” time means, either!) I’m compliant, though, and will right click like you suggested.

    Thank you!

  • I really like A Distant Mirror, and I may have mentioned these books to you before. However, Thomas Costain’s series that starts with The Conquering Family and continues with The Magnificent Century, The Three Edwards and THe Last Plantaganets provides a wonderful readable history of England during the same time period (also before and after).

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *