August 24, 2007

  • Fine Art Friday & The Grapes of Wrath

    Dorothea Lange’s Migrant Mother

    The other five images Dorothea Lange took.
    I know zip about photography, but the lesson here is clear:
    Zoom in close. Lange’s famous photograph has so much
    more power than the others; you can see the wrinkled brow.
    More about the subject, Florence Owens Thompson.

    Added Later:

    “This benefit of seeing…
    can come only if you pause a while,

    extricate yourself from the maddening mob
    of quick impressions
    ceaselessly battering our lives,

    and look thoughtfully at a quiet
    image…

    the viewer must be willing to pause,
    to look again, to
    meditate.”

    ~  Dorothea Lange

    This famous picture had to accompany the Steinbeck review.
    The obvious connection was confirmed in this quote from the Wikipedia article.

    Florence remembered that “when Steinbeck wrote in The Grapes of Wrath about those people living under the bridge in Bakersfield – at one time we lived under that bridge. It was the same story. Didn’t even have a tent then, just a ratty old quilt.”

    The Grapes of Wrath begins with a drought and ends with a flood.  The book was disturbing, uncomfortable, and yet … compelling.  Since most of you read this in high school English (why didn’t I ???) I’ll leave the plot and characters to your memory.

    I’m always comparing books.  This book reminded me in many ways of Cry, The Beloved Country.  Both deal with tragedy, injustice, greed, violence.  But more than that, they both have these incredible little essays tucked in between the chapters that move the plot along.  The commentary and descriptive prose in both are haunting; they visit your mind long after you’ve finished.

    Can we talk about obscenity and profanity in a book?  I don’t normally swear or cuss and I never use the Lord’s name casually in speech.  I inwardly cringe when someone says, “Oh God” let alone J.C. or C. Almighty.  For the most part,  my days have been insulated from a steady stream of profanity.  What I found with this audio version was the obscenity was in. your. face.  Or, rather, in my ears.  Inescapable.   I debated with myself about continuing. 

    I thought Steinbeck had a message worth listening to, an indictment on corporate business methods that starve the little farmer out of his farm.  I was sick to my stomach at the image of car loads of oranges doused with diesel and burned while people were starving, not just starving but dying, so the price of oranges stayed up.  

    So I struggled with the issue of keeping myself pure and the issue of being strong enough to sift through the grit.  This sounds unconnected, but last year I served on a grand jury rape case.   It was murky, messy, and needed the wisdom of Solomon.  At the same time that I felt slimed, I was able to inject some maturity and common sense into the debate.  I reflected that I was able to deal with the situation emotionally in a way that I wouldn’t have been able twenty years ago.

    Wiser folk have written about this.  It would be a good study for my son and I to work through. These are matters that require wisdom.

    “Wisdom doesn’t mean that you are smarter.  It means you are living out what you know.”   ~ Pastor Steve Schlissel

Comments (9)

  • Hummm I always thought that was a Margaret Bourke White photo?  Thanks for the correction. I have a son and his wife who live in Bakersfield. I cannot imagine living under anything there! I am one of those who read this in high school (unsaved back then so my remembrance is definetly coming from a different base of reference)The movie with Henry Fonda became an altered version of the book but still powerful in its message. My favorite scene is just when they are about to leave their home, the mother stands before a cracked mirror and raises an old earing, a remnant of other days, to her ear. The sorrow and memories that slowly spread across her face, deepens the pain in her eyes.  It breaks my heart. Her human dignity amidst the pain of poverty and a life filled with dissappointment sums up the book in a glance. She is an impressionism of the photo above. Thanks for this honest assessment. Blessings and love, m

  • I always have more trouble with profanity or questionable content when I am listening to a book. I guess when I’m reading it, I just skim over those spots, and it doesn’t seem to get into my mind and take up residence like it does when I hear it read aloud.

    Carrie

  • Obscenity/profanity in conversation always *shorts my wires* interrupting synapse and making comprehension impossible.

    I have never read The Grapes of Wrath.  The high school assignment of this nature that upset me the most was Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle.  Icky!

    Dana in GA

  • That whole part of history has always fascinated me, especially living in California and being so close to Salinas where Hemingway spent a lot of time.  What is interesting is that in the next span of time after the “Okies,” these jobs (in California) fell to Chicano workers, who united under Cesar Chavez, for better working conditions and pay.  And Hemingway’s style of writing – gritty – is what set him apart from so many others.  He captured the realism of the era that few others did.

  • Great quote from Schlissel!  I always tell my kids, “Wisdom is knowing the right thing to do, and doing it”.  I’m so thankful the years add some wisdom- worth every wrinkle, in my opinion!

  • I never read Grapes of Wrath in high school either. But its a funny coincidence that I just finished listening to East of Eden and have been working on the review. I also had a hard time with the harsh language while listening to it. You are so right that it is in your face.

    I would like to read Grapes of Wrath someday but need a little break from Steinbeck.

    Great review

  • I never read the book in HS either. And havn’t gotten around to reading it as my eading time is severly limited lately.  But the movie…..I rented it a little while ago from the library.  Excellent!! 

  • I read Grapes of Wrath when I was pregnant with Luke, not in high school either. I listened to Steinbeck’s “Of Mice and Men” this summer and I do remember the profanity, especially the Lord’s name being taken in vain so often.

    Here’s a link to an article I came across on The King’s College website this week. It addresses your question about whether Christians should expose ourselves to the negative things of this world in exchange for understanding the ideas, etc. of the world. I thought of the article when I read your post. Very thought provoking.

    http://www.tkc.edu/advancement/media/archives2.asp?id=27

    Blessings,

    Sandy

  • So many things to think about! I have thought about re-reading some Steinbeck as we just visited Cannery Row and spent a couple days in Monterey (last time I read him, many years ago, I came away thinking he was very depressing). There are many books included on reading lists for homeschool high school students which have some questionable and “gritty” content, though not as bad as some recommended reading in public schools. Often there is no warning for unsuspecting parents. I do think we have to prepare our children to live in this world and be shining lights, but we don’t want to cause them to stumble or be desensitized to sin. Sometimes we can deal with those things better with some maturity.

    Your experience with the trial also made me think about something a friend recently wrote to me. She and her husband postpone voter’s registration and driver’s licenses with their daughters (i.e., don’t automatically do it just because they are 16 or 18) as they don’t want them called for jury duty to be exposed to the lurid details of some of today’s crimes, like the one you mention. Your point about being able to deal with it more wisely now than when you were younger is a good one. I would be concerned about my daughters having to face such things. I know my views are considered controversial, even among Christians, but there it is .

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *